CHARLESTON, W.Va. — A federal grand jury indicted West Virginia State Auditor Mark Hunt and four others in alleged property theft and payroll schemes, the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of West Virginia announced Monday.
Hunt, 66, allegedly issued nine improper tax deeds benefiting longtime associate Robert Lisle Johns, 66, of Charleston, according to the department.
The properties were in Kanawha and Boone counties. Hunt allegedly signed eight deeds on March 28, 2025, and the ninth on June 6, 2025.
Advertisement · House ad

Tiesonomo Media Group, LLC
Put your brand in the conversation.
Let’s talk ↗Tiesonomo Media Group, LLC is Tysonomo Multimedia’s parent company. Promotions for its media services are house advertisements and are labeled separately from news coverage. Advertising purchases placement, not editorial treatment. Our advertising policy.
Johns was associated with the business seeking the properties. He became the auditor’s full-time special counsel in June 2025, according to the department.
Prosecutors said career employees determined the properties were ineligible because the purchaser missed required payments and paperwork deadlines.
However, Hunt allegedly issued the deeds despite those objections.
Hunt, Johns, Deputy Chief of Staff David Keith Cole, 57, and General Counsel Frederic Scott Caudill, 59, all of Charleston, each face nine property theft counts.
Additionally, Cole and Caudill each face one count of making materially false statements to federal investigators.
Meanwhile, employee Marie Hoffman, 66, of Hurricane, allegedly collected state wages for work performed at Hunt’s private law firm.
Prosecutors allege Hunt knew about the arrangement and Cole approved falsified timecards. Hunt and Cole also face charges alleging they aided the bank fraud.
The alleged payroll scheme ran from May 2025 through at least September 2026.
Prosecutors said Hoffmann left her government workplace on Friday afternoons to perform paralegal and administrative work at Hunt’s law firm.
Hoffman was paid state wages for her work at the private law firm with Hunt’s knowledge and after Cole validated and approved her falsified government timecards, the department explained.
Cole also managed Hunt’s private law office while serving as the auditor’s deputy chief of staff, according to the department.
If convicted, defendants face maximum prison terms of 10 years for property theft, five years for false statements and 30 years for bank fraud, depending on their charges.
The indictments contain allegations only. All defendants are presumed innocent unless proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.


Join the discussion
We encourage respectful civil discourse. Reader comments are reviewed before publication. Read our discussion policy.